Can Two Roosters Live Together Without Hens?

[HenThusiast]

My friend has two mature roosters that were raised together in a flock with hens. Unfortunately, theyve started overbreeding and stressing the hens, likely because there arent enough to go around. Separating them seems like the best option, but rehoming or culling them is not on the table.

The plan is to set up a separate coop and run for just the two roosters, where they can hear but not see the hens. Since theyve always lived together, will they coexist peacefully without hens, or will the lack of females turn them against each other? Would adding more hens be a better solution?

Id love to hear from anyone who has experience with rooster bachelor pads or similar situations. Is this a recipe for fighting, or could they adjust to life without hens? Thanks in advance for any advice!

[OpheliaOrpington]

My friend has two mature roosters that were raised together in a flock with hens. Unfortunately, theyve started overbreeding and stressing the hens, likely because there arent enough to go around. Separating them seems like the best option, but rehoming or culling them is not on the table.

The plan is to set up a separate coop and run for just the two roosters, where they can hear but not see the hens. Since theyve always lived together, will they coexist peacefully without hens, or will the lack of females turn them against each other? Would adding more hens be a better solution?

Id love to hear from anyone who has experience with rooster bachelor pads or similar situations. Is this a recipe for fighting, or could they adjust to life without hens? Thanks in advance for any advice!

Some roosters thrive in bachelor pads, but others won't. If they start fighting, consider visual barriers, separate feeding areas, or even a larger space.

[SunriseChirp]

A rooster bachelor pen can work well, but it depends on the temperament of the birds. Some roosters remain bonded without hens, while others may see each other as rivals once the hens are removed. To increase your chances of success, ensure they have ample space, multiple feeding and watering stations, and things to keep them occupied, such as perches or areas to explore. Keeping them out of sight of the hens can also reduce stress and aggression. However, if fighting persists, be ready with a backup plan, such as dividing the run or housing them separately.

[OliviaOrpington]

Removing hens often reduces aggression between roosters. If they get along, they might actually enjoy the company. If fights break out, extra space or separation may be needed.

[NestingNerd]

Rooster flocks are common in setups where hens aren't available, and they can coexist peacefully with the right management. Since these two have a history of living together, they have a better chance of getting along. However, the absence of hens can shift their dynamics. When transitioning them to a bachelor pen, monitor their behavior closely for the first few weeks. If signs of aggression emerge, consider giving them more space, adding enrichment, or even blocking sound from the hens if possible. Sometimes roosters fight due to boredom rather than competition.

[CoopRebel]

If culling isn't an option and adding hens isn't feasible, a bachelor coop is your best bet. Roosters often adjust well to life without hens, but watch for dominance struggles. Giving them space and enrichment, like different perch levels and dust baths, can help reduce tension. Keeping them within hearing distance but out of sight of the hens can also minimize conflict. If they start fighting, be ready to separate them temporarily to prevent serious injuries.

[RuralRooster]

My friend has two mature roosters that were raised together in a flock with hens. Unfortunately, theyve started overbreeding and stressing the hens, likely because there arent enough to go around. Separating them seems like the best option, but rehoming or culling them is not on the table.

The plan is to set up a separate coop and run for just the two roosters, where they can hear but not see the hens. Since theyve always lived together, will they coexist peacefully without hens, or will the lack of females turn them against each other? Would adding more hens be a better solution?

Id love to hear from anyone who has experience with rooster bachelor pads or similar situations. Is this a recipe for fighting, or could they adjust to life without hens? Thanks in advance for any advice!

Bachelor flocks often do well! Just make sure they have plenty of space, distractions, and no direct sight of the hens to reduce tension.

[TheBroodyOne]

Bachelor flocks work for some roosters but not all. A trial period is best,be prepared to separate if needed. Watch for signs of bullying or stress.